Our Story

Midtown made.
New York loved.

Since 1965

More than fifty years of keeping 45th Street fed.

Little Italy Pizza has always been about quality, speed, and that unmistakable New York pizzeria rhythm. Our counter has welcomed loyal locals, office regulars, and visitors from around the world.

From a quick Neapolitan slice to a full catering spread, we make food for the way Midtown moves. This is our only location, and we are proud to call West 45th Street home.

Direct Order Now
The pizza counter at Little Italy PizzaFresh margherita pizzaPizza dough being prepared
Order Now